I had given up. My previously-documented enthusiasm for SQLite had run dry, and I had already hammered out another solution. Then Charlie stepped in and saved the day with a window function.
I’m currently perusing the open data portals of The Bundesrepublik Deutschland, looking at the wealth of aerial photography that is available as a public good. The ultimate aim is the constant improvement of the Mapbox Satellite baselayer, but I love how much I learn in the process, both about place and data.
In the case of the State of Lower Saxony, there’s a great collection of 20cm-resolution orthophotos with varying recency. More importantly, there’s good metadata. With a click, I was able to download a GeoJSON file containing the source, location, and vintage of every pixel in the region (except for Bremen, I guess?).
Orthophoto coverage for the state of Lower Saxony, Germany. The darker the tile, the greater the number of archived imagery acquisitions available.
However, this file contains multiple imagery acquisitions in one place; I only want the most recent available imagery.
The flailing hack
I am accustomed to solving this problem with the power of SQL, one way or another. Of late I’ve been trying to fit as much geoprocessing and general transforming as possible into single commands, and the mighty
ogr2ogr toolkit is my go-to. However, the center of much of its power is in the
-sql parameter, and the standard dialect is SQLite. Crucially, SQLite does not permit ordering of records in aggregate functions.
After hammering away optimistically for a few iterations, I gave up and retreated to the comfy cushions of the PostgreSQL lounge, though it required some configuration and a data roundtrip into the DB and back:
# Get the metadata wget -c https://single-datasets.opengeodata.lgln.niedersachsen.de/pro-download-indices/dop/lgln-opengeodata-dop20.geojson # Set up the PostgreSQL environment dropdb lower_saxony --if-exists createdb lower_saxony psql lower_saxony -c "CREATE EXTENSION postgis;" # Import the metadata to the new DB ogr2ogr -t_srs "EPSG:4326" \ -f "PostgreSQL" \ PG:"dbname=lower_saxony" \ lgln-opengeodata-dop20.geojson \ -nln lower_saxony # Filter for the latest imagery records in each location, using ordered aggregates like a barbarian psql lower_saxony -c " DROP TABLE IF EXISTS lower_saxony_latest; CREATE TABLE lower_saxony_latest AS ( SELECT tile_id, (array_agg(Aktualitaet ORDER BY Aktualitaet DESC)) AS date, (array_agg(rgb ORDER BY Aktualitaet DESC)) AS rgb, (array_agg(rgb_metadata ORDER BY Aktualitaet DESC)) AS rgb_metadata FROM lower_saxony GROUP BY tile_id ) " # Export to a CSV list ogr2ogr \ -f CSV \ lower_saxony_latest.csv \ PG:"dbname=lower_saxony" \ -sql "SELECT tile_id,TO_CHAR(date, 'YYYY-MM-DD’) AS date, rgb, rgb_metadata FROM lower_saxony_latest"
My god, what a long-winded bummer.
The actual solution
The aforementioned Charlie (Charlie Lefrak, data savant and good dude) thought there was no need to involve PostgreSQL, and after some digging he was able to solve the problem much more elegantly, still within the umbrella of
ogr2ogr. He did it with a window function, which it turns out is fully supported by SQLite:
# Get the metadata wget -c https://single-datasets.opengeodata.lgln.niedersachsen.de/pro-download-indices/dop/lgln-opengeodata-dop20.geojson # Run it all in one shot through ogr2ogr, ordering with a window function like a civilized human ogr2ogr -f CSV \ lower_saxony_latest.csv \ lgln-opengeodata-dop20.geojson \ -dialect sqlite \ -sql " SELECT * FROM ( SELECT tile_id, strftime('%Y-%m-%d',Aktualitaet) AS date, rgb, rgb_metadata, RANK () OVER ( PARTITION BY tile_id ORDER BY Aktualitaet DESC ) r FROM 'lgln-opengeodata-dop20' ) RANKED WHERE r = 1"
This solution - leveraging the
RANK () function to identify the latest date - is the winner, because
- It’s shorter.
- There’s no database overhead (I mean, there is, but it’s hidden by the glory of SQLite).
- It’s very reusable.
I could parameterize this snippet as a function and put it to work on the inevitably-similar data structures of North Rhine-Westphalia! Of Hesse! Even of [other] Saxony!
I hope it’s of use to you too, good reader. Zum Wohl!
The Hanover Hauptbannhof, in all its early-summer glory, acquired May 8, 2022.